Constitutional Parental Rights: No "Substantive Due Process" Required
Document Type
Article
Publication Title
Constitutional Parental Rights: No "Substantive Due Process" Required
Abstract
The cause of parental rights achieved a major victory this past spring. In Mirabelli v. Bonta, the Supreme Court granted parents emergency relief against a state policy whereby school officials would identify a child as “transgender,” and then, without notice to his or her parents, begin calling the boy a girl (or the girl a boy). The Court found that this policy likely violated the parents’ constitutional right to direct the “upbringing and education” of their children.
The decision signaled a victory not only for parental rights, but also for conservative jurisprudence more generally. Chief Justice John Roberts, setting aside his prior doubts, joined an opinion that reaffirmed the principal holding in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health: that the “substantive” rights secured by the Fourteenth Amendment are limited to those “deeply rooted in [our] Nation’s history and tradition.” Now there are six justices who have set aside the evolutionary approach to the Amendment (which garnered five votes in Obergefell) and expressly endorsed the fundamentalist reading.
But there is grave instability in the conservative position. As Justice Kagan noted in her dissent, the majority relied on a doctrine—“substantive due process”—that Justice Thomas and other conservative jurists have often questioned, if not rejected.
Publication Date
8-12-2026
Recommended Citation
David Upham, Constitutional Parental Rights: No "Substantive Due Process" Required, Public Discourse (Aug. 12, 2026).